Hugh Grant’s Villainous Turn in Heretic: A Mixed Bag of Terrors and Triumphs

In Scott Beck and Bryan Woods’ latest edgy religious horror film, Heretic, Hugh Grant portrays Mr. Reid, an intellectual theologian with a sinister edge. Known for his charming roles in Bridget Jones and Notting Hill, Grant brings a reptilian charisma to his character, who engages in intense debates with two young Mormon missionaries.

A Charismatic Villain With a Dark Twist

Grant’s portrayal of Mr. Reid is a standout, casting him in a role that challenges his usual typecasting. The film, premiering at the Toronto International Film Festival and set for a theatrical release on November 15, portrays Grant as a convincing villain, leading to questions about why he doesn’t take on more sinister roles.

Warm Welcome Turns Sinister

Mr. Reid initially appears hospitable, inviting Sisters Paxton and Barnes into his home with offers of blueberry pie and engaging conversation. However, his unsettling demeanor and intrusive questions soon reveal a more malevolent nature, setting the stage for a harrowing experience.

Atmosphere and Suspense: A Crafty Combination

Beck and Woods, known for their work on A Quiet Place, build tension through meticulous set design. Cinematographer Jung Jeong-hoon and art director Philip Messina craft an eerie atmosphere, using details like sickly yellow wallpaper and sparse windows to unsettle both the characters and the audience.

A Gripping Revelation

The film reaches a peak with a chilling scene where Mr. Reid reveals his disturbing conclusions about faith. His eccentric and fanatic delivery, combined with a peculiar mix of props including a Monopoly board, creates a memorable and unsettling moment.

Strong Performances Amidst a Wobbly Plot

Heretic shines in its early scenes, with compelling performances from Chloe East and Sophie Thatcher. East’s Sister Burns offers a sharp critique of Reid’s logic, while Thatcher’s portrayal of Sister Paxton highlights her naivety. Despite the gripping tension, the film’s plot falters under the weight of its thematic ambitions.

A Compelling But Flawed Narrative

The film’s most engaging aspect is the dynamic between Reid, Paxton, and Burns. The cat-and-mouse game drives the narrative, even as the script struggles with its critique of modern religion. The transition from philosophical debate to conventional horror feels abrupt, leaving some thematic promises unfulfilled.

Conclusion: A Mixed Experience

Heretic offers a memorable performance from Hugh Grant and an intriguing central conflict, but ultimately, it falls short of its potential. While the film’s tension and character dynamics are strong, the screenplay’s weaknesses and the film’s shift to conventional horror diminish its impact.